Dr. McCoy, Surly Surgeon

Star Trek #14

Dr. McCoy, Surly Surgeon - Star Trek

Type: Legendary Creature — Human Doctor

Mana cost: {2}{W}{W}

Card text: When Dr. McCoy enters, put a +1/+1 counter on another target creature you control. If another creature you control with a +1/+1 counter on it would be destroyed, instead remove all +1/+1 counters from it and all damage already dealt to it is healed.

P/T: 2/2

Rarity: uncommon

Artist: David Robert Hovey

""What is this, the Dark Ages?!""

Released: November 13, 2026

Prices

$0.25 USD · $0.35 USD (Foil) · €0.07 EUR

Buy This Card

Format Legality

FormatLegality
Standard✓ Legal
Pioneer✓ Legal
Modern✓ Legal
Legacy✓ Legal
Commander✓ Legal
Vintage✓ Legal
Pauper✗ Not Legal
Oathbreaker✓ Legal

Is Dr. McCoy, Surly Surgeon good in Star Trek Limited?

In Star Trek Limited we rate Dr. McCoy, Surly Surgeon B tier — a strong, solid playable.

Ratings come from the draft tier list for Star Trek and from reviews submitted by players in the Limited set review.

Draft & Sealed Synergies

Best cards to pair with Dr. McCoy, Surly Surgeon in Star Trek limited

common

Emergency Medical Hologram
Emergency Medical Hologram
Artifact Creature — Illusion Doctor

EMH puts a +1/+1 counter on a creature when it enters, and Dr. McCoy's protection ability then shields that creature from destruction by removing those counters instead, creating a resilient board presence.

Federation Field Medic
Federation Field Medic
Creature — Human Doctor

Federation Field Medic places +1/+1 counters on creatures, and Dr. McCoy's ability protects those countered creatures from being destroyed, making the counters serve double duty as both a buff and a shield.

Pure Energy
Pure Energy
Sorcery

Pure Energy distributes +1/+1 counters, and Dr. McCoy ensures those countered creatures survive removal by stripping counters instead of dying, making the investment in counters much more durable.

rare

Deanna Troi, Psychic Counsel
Deanna Troi, Psychic Counsel
Legendary Creature — Betazoid Human Advisor

Deanna Troi adds an extra counter whenever counters are placed, and Dr. McCoy's enter trigger placing a counter becomes two counters, while McCoy's protection ability keeps those heavily-countered creatures alive.

mythic

Dr. Joseph M'Benga
Dr. Joseph M'Benga
Legendary Creature — Human Doctor

Dr. M'Benga doubles all counters placed on creatures, so McCoy's enter trigger becomes two counters, and M'Benga's hexproof for countered creatures combined with McCoy's destruction replacement creates nearly invincible creatures.

Related Articles

Federation Fleet Upgrade Guide: 12 Upgrades to Power Up Jean-Luc Picard, Luminary

Federation Fleet Upgrade Guide: 12 Upgrades to Power Up Jean-Luc Picard, Luminary

Upgrade the Star Trek Commander Federation Fleet precon (Blue-Red-White historic and card flow) with 12 additions and 12 cuts across two tiers, built around Jean-Luc Picard, Luminary.

2026-10-29
Klingon Fury Upgrade Guide: 12 Upgrades to Power Up Worf, Defiant Commander

Klingon Fury Upgrade Guide: 12 Upgrades to Power Up Worf, Defiant Commander

Upgrade the Star Trek Commander Klingon Fury precon (Red-White-Black Klingon and Warrior aggro) with 12 additions and 12 cuts across two tiers, built around Worf, Defiant Commander.

2026-10-29
Magic: The Gathering Star Trek Products Guide: Every Product, Price and Date

Magic: The Gathering Star Trek Products Guide: Every Product, Price and Date

Every Star Trek Magic product explained: Play and Collector Boosters, the four Commander decks, Collector's Edition, bundles, Draft Night, Scene Boxes, Stardates, prices and dates.

2026-10-29
We Are the Borg Upgrade Guide: 12 Upgrades to Power Up The Borg Queen

We Are the Borg Upgrade Guide: 12 Upgrades to Power Up The Borg Queen

Upgrade the Star Trek Commander We Are the Borg precon (White-Blue-Black artifact creatures) with 12 additions and 12 cuts across two tiers, built around The Borg Queen.

2026-10-29