Impossible Choice

Star Trek #116

Impossible Choice - Star Trek

Type: Instant

Mana cost: {2}{B}

Card text: Choose one — • Surgical Separation — Destroy target creature. Its controller creates two 1/1 red Officer creature tokens. • Remain Fused — You draw two cards and each player loses 2 life.

Rarity: uncommon

Artist: Douglas Shuler

"Saving Neelix and Tuvok meant destroying the person they'd become."

Released: November 13, 2026

Prices

$0.26 USD · $0.32 USD (Foil) · €0.02 EUR

Buy This Card

Format Legality

FormatLegality
Standard✓ Legal
Pioneer✓ Legal
Modern✓ Legal
Legacy✓ Legal
Commander✓ Legal
Vintage✓ Legal
Pauper✗ Not Legal
Oathbreaker✓ Legal

Draft & Sealed Synergies

Best cards to pair with Impossible Choice in Star Trek limited

common

Obsidian Order Operative
Obsidian Order Operative
Creature — Cardassian Officer Spy

Impossible Choice is a modal spell that counts as facing a dilemma, triggering Obsidian Order Operative to drain each opponent for 1 life whenever you cast it.

Fugitive Listener
Fugitive Listener
Creature — El-Aurian Scout

Impossible Choice's Surgical Separation mode destroys a creature and gives opponents tokens, while Remain Fused draws cards and drains life, both modes generating value alongside Fugitive Listener's hand disruption.

uncommon

Gabriel Lorca, Mirror Menace
Gabriel Lorca, Mirror Menace
Legendary Creature — Human Rogue Officer

Impossible Choice faces a dilemma, allowing Gabriel Lorca to pay {B} and return from the graveyard to hand, making this instant a reliable recursion trigger for Lorca.

Tell Me What You See
Tell Me What You See
Enchantment

Tell Me What You See can be returned to hand whenever you face a dilemma; casting Impossible Choice triggers this return, letting you replay Tell Me What You See for repeated value.

rare

Elim Garak, Simple Tailor
Elim Garak, Simple Tailor
Legendary Creature — Cardassian Rogue

Elim Garak drains 2 life from each opponent whenever you face a dilemma, and Impossible Choice is a modal instant that counts as facing a dilemma, making it a reliable drain trigger.

Related Articles

Federation Fleet Upgrade Guide: 12 Upgrades to Power Up Jean-Luc Picard, Luminary

Federation Fleet Upgrade Guide: 12 Upgrades to Power Up Jean-Luc Picard, Luminary

Upgrade the Star Trek Commander Federation Fleet precon (Blue-Red-White historic and card flow) with 12 additions and 12 cuts across two tiers, built around Jean-Luc Picard, Luminary.

2026-10-29
Klingon Fury Upgrade Guide: 12 Upgrades to Power Up Worf, Defiant Commander

Klingon Fury Upgrade Guide: 12 Upgrades to Power Up Worf, Defiant Commander

Upgrade the Star Trek Commander Klingon Fury precon (Red-White-Black Klingon and Warrior aggro) with 12 additions and 12 cuts across two tiers, built around Worf, Defiant Commander.

2026-10-29
Magic: The Gathering Star Trek Products Guide: Every Product, Price and Date

Magic: The Gathering Star Trek Products Guide: Every Product, Price and Date

Every Star Trek Magic product explained: Play and Collector Boosters, the four Commander decks, Collector's Edition, bundles, Draft Night, Scene Boxes, Stardates, prices and dates.

2026-10-29
We Are the Borg Upgrade Guide: 12 Upgrades to Power Up The Borg Queen

We Are the Borg Upgrade Guide: 12 Upgrades to Power Up The Borg Queen

Upgrade the Star Trek Commander We Are the Borg precon (White-Blue-Black artifact creatures) with 12 additions and 12 cuts across two tiers, built around The Borg Queen.

2026-10-29