Painful Quandary

Foundations #179

Painful Quandary - Foundations

Type: Enchantment

Mana cost: {3}{B}{B}

Card text: Whenever an opponent casts a spell, that player loses 5 life unless they discard a card.

Rarity: rare

Artist: David Palumbo

"In Mishra's desperation to destroy his brother, he allowed Gix to destroy him instead."

Released: November 15, 2024

Prices

$2.17 USD · $2.03 USD (Foil) · €0.96 EUR

Buy This Card

Format Legality

FormatLegality
Standard✓ Legal
Pioneer✓ Legal
Modern✓ Legal
Legacy✓ Legal
Commander✓ Legal
Vintage✓ Legal
Pauper✗ Not Legal
Oathbreaker✓ Legal

Painful Quandary Price History & Market Trend

Daily USD and EUR price tracking for Painful Quandary (Foundations #179), last 30 snapshots.

Over the last 30 days Painful Quandary has fallen to $0.99, 34.4% below its $1.51 high on 2026-11-12 and 8.8% above its $0.91 low on 2026-11-19.

Current
$0.99
7-day change
-18.9%
Period high
$1.51
2026-11-12
Period low
$0.91
2026-11-19
DateUSDEURUSD FoilEUR Foil
2026-10-24 $1.15 0.97€ $1.84 1.33€
2026-10-25 $1.02 0.97€ $1.84 1.35€
2026-10-26 $1.04 0.99€ $1.84 1.35€
2026-10-27 $1.04 0.98€ $1.84 1.32€
2026-10-28 $1.1 0.97€ $1.84 1.38€
2026-10-29 $0.98 1.02€ $1.84 1.36€
2026-10-30 $0.99 1€ $1.84 1.33€
2026-10-31 $1.01 0.99€ $1.84 1.35€
2026-11-01 $1 1€ $1.84 1.43€
2026-11-02 $1.1 1€ $1.84 1.43€
2026-11-03 $1.49 1.08€ $1.84 1.47€
2026-11-04 $1.09 1.08€ $1.84 1.47€
2026-11-05 $1.31 1.09€ $1.84 1.53€
2026-11-06 $1.33 1.07€ $1.84 1.52€
2026-11-07 $1.29 1.07€ $1.88 1.46€
2026-11-08 $1.11 1.12€ $1.88 1.5€
2026-11-09 $1.08 1.12€ $1.88 1.5€
2026-11-10 $1.19 1.03€ $1.88 1.47€
2026-11-11 $1.26 1.03€ $1.94 1.47€
2026-11-12 $1.51 1.06€ $1.76 1.47€
2026-11-13 $1.35 1.07€ $1.76 1.43€
2026-11-14 $1.34 1.03€ $1.76 1.39€
2026-11-15 $1.22 1.03€ $1.69 1.39€
2026-11-16 $1.38 1.02€ $1.67 1.33€
2026-11-17 $1.44 1.02€ $1.67 1.33€
2026-11-18 $1.19 0.98€ $1.67 1.33€
2026-11-19 $0.91 0.98€ $1.67 1.33€
2026-11-20 $0.99 1€ $1.6 1.35€
2026-11-21 $0.99 0.96€ $1.45 1.45€
2026-11-22 $0.99 0.96€ $1.45 1.45€

Draft & Sealed Synergies

Best cards to pair with Painful Quandary in Foundations limited

common

Burglar Rat
Burglar Rat
Creature — Rat

Forces discard when it enters, making opponents more likely to take damage from Painful Quandary when casting spells.

Pilfer
Pilfer
Sorcery

Strips cards from the opponent's hand, making every spell they cast with Painful Quandary in play more painful.

Stab
Stab
Instant

Provides cheap removal to protect Painful Quandary and maintain control while opponents take damage from casting spells.

rare

Tinybones, Bauble Burglar
Tinybones, Bauble Burglar
Legendary Creature — Skeleton Rogue

Forces discard and benefits from opponents discarding to Painful Quandary, creating a powerful discard lock strategy.

Phyrexian Arena
Phyrexian Arena
Enchantment

Draws extra cards to maintain resources while Painful Quandary grinds opponents down, supporting a long-game control strategy.

Related Articles

Calling All Angels Upgrade Guide: 12 Upgrades to Power Up Giada, Font of Hope

Calling All Angels Upgrade Guide: 12 Upgrades to Power Up Giada, Font of Hope

Upgrade the Foundations Commander Calling All Angels precon (mono-white Angels) with 12 additions and 12 cuts across two tiers, built around Giada, Font of Hope.

2026-10-05
Keen Engineering Upgrade Guide: 12 Upgrades to Power Up Sai, Master Thopterist

Keen Engineering Upgrade Guide: 12 Upgrades to Power Up Sai, Master Thopterist

Upgrade the Foundations Commander Keen Engineering precon (mono-blue artifacts) with 12 additions and 12 cuts across two tiers, built around Sai, Master Thopterist.

2026-10-05
Reign of Dragons Upgrade Guide: 12 Upgrades to Power Up Lathliss, Dragon Queen

Reign of Dragons Upgrade Guide: 12 Upgrades to Power Up Lathliss, Dragon Queen

Upgrade the Foundations Commander Reign of Dragons precon (mono-red Dragons) with 12 additions and 12 cuts across two tiers, built around Lathliss, Dragon Queen.

2026-10-05
Tramplesaurus Rex Upgrade Guide: 12 Upgrades to Power Up Ghalta, Primal Hunger

Tramplesaurus Rex Upgrade Guide: 12 Upgrades to Power Up Ghalta, Primal Hunger

Upgrade the Foundations Commander Tramplesaurus Rex precon (mono-green Dinosaurs) with 12 additions and 12 cuts across two tiers, built around Ghalta, Primal Hunger.

2026-10-05